Can Islam Be Reformed? What does the Quran say about Jews & extremism? Imam answers tough questions
Sheikh Paul Salahuddin Armstrong in conversation with Jonathan Sacerdoti – a searching, honest, and at times tense exploration of Islam, extremism, reform, and coexistence. From the trauma of 9/11 to questions about child marriage, apostasy, and Israel, this dialogue confronts difficult truths and conflicting worldviews. Armstrong, a reformist British imam, defends his spiritual understanding of Islam while Sacerdoti challenges him with frank concerns as a British Jew raised in the shadow of terrorism. Their exchange offers rare insight into both common ground and irreconcilable tensions.
We discuss:
• The misuse of Islam by extremists
• Whether Muhammad was perfect
• If Islam needs reform or reinterpretation
• Islamic preaching in Britain
• Israel, the Palestinians, and the Abraham Accords
• Leaving Islam, child marriage, homosexuality
• The future of British Islam
Chapters:
1:25 Why Sheikh Armstrong was drawn to Islam
3:03 The shock of 9/11 and discovering extremism
4:20 “The Quran spoke to me like nothing else”
5:45 Learning about Judaism through Islam
6:45 Extremist verses: misunderstood or revealing?
8:06 The misuse of Islam by violent ideologues
10:11 “They wear Islam like a cloak for fascism”
12:03 Are extremists still Muslims?
13:08 “terrified of Islam” – a Jewish view
14:05 Extremist Muslims in Britain vs. abroad
15:15 Does Islam have a problem with conquest?
16:55 State religion, secularism, and freedom
18:53 Does liberal democracy risk being overrun?
20:30 How reformist Islam can coexist with British values
23:01 Islam’s view on homosexuality and women
24:00 The Mosab Hassan Yousef challenge
25:55 “That’s not the Islam I know”
27:12 Muhammad, the Jews of Medina, and historical context
29:11 “I’m horrified by today’s jihadis”
30:48 Making peaceful Islam mainstream
32:35 Abraham Accords and modern interfaith hope
33:01 Can you criticise Muhammad and remain Muslim?
34:44 “I don’t believe he married a 9-year-old”
36:00 Islam, Jews, and the fear of Zionism
38:30 “I left a mosque feeling dirty and ashamed”
39:55 Should Britain regulate Friday sermons?
41:12 “Reading the Quran helped me understand Judaism”
43:02 Why Islam addresses Jews and Christians
44:19 Islam as an evangelising religion?
45:57 “Good Jews, good Christians, good people of God”
47:00 Apostasy and its punishment – then and now
49:00 His first Quran and initial rejection of Islam
50:40 A Westerner’s horror reading the Quran
52:01 Personal responsibility and Islam’s spiritual appeal
54:11 The Israeli-Palestinian conflict and Islam
57:18 Why peace can’t happen under Hamas
59:36 “Why do they teach kids to hate?”
1:00:17 Raising children without forcing belief
1:02:12 The leadership crisis in British Islam
1:04:40 Ignorance and extremism in Muslim communities
1:06:08 The Jews of Medina – what really happened?
1:07:27 Muhammad’s vision of multi-faith coexistence
1:09:54 Jizya, dhimmi status, and equality
1:12:15 Reclaiming a just, modern Islam in Britain
1:16:05 Can Islam adapt to British society?
1:17:47 The stakes: reformers vs. extremists
1:19:02 Why the police failed to act on grooming gangs
1:21:04 Can promoting moderate Islam backfire?